A Wednesday (Movie Review)
Terrorism turned inside out in this engaging thriller
First things first. "A Wednesday" is not about the train blasts that rocked Mumbai in 2005. It isn't so much to do about terrorism and counter-terrorism as it is about making these grim socio-political facts into digestible riveting cinema.
And that's where "A Wednesday" scores over "Mumbai Meri Jaan" and other recent films on the wrath of extremism.
Debutant director Neeraj Pandey turns the grim reality of terrorism into an engaging cat-and-mouse game played between a master blaster (Naseeruddin Shah) and a senior cop (Anupam Kher).
Just the pleasure of watching Naseer and Anupam against the backdrop of a teeming bustling sinisterly jeopardised Mumbai city is ample reason to discard all our other misgivings about the sheer feasibility of the plot.
Cleverly the narration manoeuvres all the physical action away from the two ageing protagonists to a couple of hot-blooded young cops played effectively by Jimmy Shergill and Aamir Bashir, who hurl into camera range in a meteoric rush of adrenaline to remind us that the streets of Mumbai have always created a flutter in the clutter in our films. Just go back to every film from "Satya" to "Aamir" and see what we mean.
Cinematographer Fuwad Khan captures the blood on the roads of Mumbai with a disaffected relish. A lot of the film has been shot in stylish top-shots where the terrorists and counter-terrorist manoeuvrings appear larger than life and yet miraculously shrunken in the cosmic scheme of things. Violence in this way is made both comic and cosmic.
Most of the film cracks the entertainment code through the ongoing dialogue between the cop and the master-blaster, quite in Clint Eastwood and John Malvokich in Wolfgang Petersen's "In The Line Of Fire", triggering off a thought-provoking chain of ideas on the common man and terrorism and how far the violence of extremism affects the self-worth of the middle class.
The closing lap of the edge-of-the-seat is a clever plot-defining twist, perhaps too clever for its own good. For, what we get here is terrorism turned inside out, the anguish of extremism facing upside-down. It's an interesting but unacceptable end game, more suited to Quentin Tarantino when all the while we were looking at Pandey's film as belonging to Mahesh Bhatt's genre of cinema.
By the time Naseer's eruptive enthusiasm climaxes, the narration goes into the realm of the improbable, contriving to create an atmosphere of utter escapism in a film that you thought was stubbornly wedded to reality.
But that's where Pandey has been heading all along. His narrative hurtles towards a photo-finish where the newspaper headlines are swallowed up in a swamp of thriller-rituals that take the plot aback to create an aura of unstoppable suspense.
Sanjoy Chowdhury's background music over-punctuates every sequence. But then that's precisely what this out-of-the-box terrorist-thriller was looking for.
The humour, when it strikes, is like the bomb blasts. Sudden and unexpected, though a little on the grimmer side.
Veejay Gaurav Chopra as a scared film star getting extortion calls is mousy enough to remind us that heroes don't come out of the movies. But heroic movies surely do come along once in a while from the movie industry. "A Wednesday" is certainly one of them.
Watch it to see how cleverly the director subverts the real-life headline-driven genre of cinema into a riveting race to the finish line.
Most of all it's the performances of the two principal actors that holds "A Wednesday" together. Moving away from his recent comic antics, Anupam delivers a controlled performance as a cop who has seen it all. He happily allows Naseer to take over many scenes giving his co-star some riveting reactive cues.
Naseer is back in full form after a rather embarrassing gap of cameo-commitments. Naseer in his element is an experience that needs no definition. He plays the jaded but spirited bomb-planting anonymous caller with a wry blunt and edgy sardonicism creating for his character a space that pitches his angst in the wide open loosely defined crowds of desolation in Mumbai.
"A Wednesday" is not quite the seamless little masterpiece on terrorism that you expected. It resorts to many wild swipes in the plot. Some characters like the dude-like computer hacker and the TV journalist, played by Deepal Shaw, give embarrassing single-note performance.
Watch Naseer and Anupam to know how a one-to-one drama works when two actors provide a psychological and emotional equilibrium from the two ends of the moral spectrum.
Cast: Naseeruddin Shah, Anupam Kher, Jimmy Shergill, Aamir Bashir, Deepal Shaw
Writer-Director: Neeraj Pandey
Producer: Anjum Rizvi, Shital Bhatia
Indo-Asian News Service
Naseeruddin Shah Related Articles & Photos
Previews November 29,2008
Maharathi
Greed, hidden agendas and deception form the crux of this thriller Read it...
Reviews October 19,2008
Shoot On Sight (Movie Review)
Director uses economy of expression to great effect Read it...
Previews October 11,2008
Shoot On Sight
A fictional story based on the London bombings of July 2005 Read it...
Breaking News September 23,2008
Naseer replaces Amitabh in Maharathi
It's based on a play by Paresh Rawal Read it...
Feature September 16,2008
Three films, three shades of terrorism
But the theme is not doing well at the box office Read it...
Breaking News September 16,2008
Naseeruddin Shah or Victor Banerjee?
Director Dholakia undecided about whom to cast as a separatist leader Read it...
Breaking News September 9,2008
Stereotyped portrayal of Muslims annoys me
Naseeruddin Shah says filmmakers need to get their research right Read it...
Naseeruddin Shah Photos
Ritchie Mehta directs Naseeruddin Shah in "Amal" See it...
Comments
-
comments 1-4 of 4
by isha, india
i wud suggest that this movie shud b reccommend to b screened in colleges/schools too! its a very nice movie which voices the feelings of a common man/woman! finally a nice movie after a long long time!
posted 24 September 2008, 01:38 AM UAE time.
by Syed Shaheen, Kuwait
YES and 100 times YES it is a lovely film to watch ... and YES (again) amazing acting by two leading actors of bollywood ... and YES (once again) script, direction and story all are 5 Star ... BUT !!!!! the film is not for Oscars .... the only reason is, there is no Idian Heritage, no Indian Look, and no Indian outfits ... When Peheli was recomended on BLACK for oscars, above where the reasons for it. Hats of to two leading bollywood actors, and hats given to Hemish to learn from them.
posted 14 September 2008, 01:32 PM UAE time.
by DUSHYANT BAGHEL, delhi, INDIA
GREAT MOVIE TO LEARN MUST WATCH MOVIE. MUST WATCH FOR COMMON MAN. MUST WATCH FOR TRUE INDIAN. THANKS NASIRUDDIN UNCLE FOR SUCH A REAL ACTNG AND PROVING MOVIE IS NOT ALL ABOUT DANCE AND DRAMA. DUSHYANT BAGHEL
posted 14 September 2008, 07:16 AM UAE time.
by Dhawal
If EVER a movie REALLY deserved to go into the Oscars from India, this should be the one. Hats off to Neeraj Pandey, Naseeruddin Shah, Anupam Kher and the entire crew for making a film which really deserves to complete the 'Trilogy' after Aamir and Mumbai Meri Jaan. If there is a kind soul who wants to invest some money for registering a website domain which could voice in for the submission for A Wednesday as the official entry into the Oscars this year under best foreign picture category, pls contact me. I will be more than happy to design some webpages for it. This film should be india's entry for oscar's because 1. It is a SHORT pic (1.5 hours only) 2. No songs 3. 2 Top actors (Shah and Kher) giving performance of the year 4. Extremely well character selection 5. Obviously - "THE MESSAGE" of the Stupid Common Man 6. Showing the police dept in good light (rarely this happens in bollywood) 7. Shows the 'Solution', NOT the 'problem' - unlike Aamir and Mumbai meri jaan. 8. Accurate potrayal of media - their good AND bad points 9. FANTASTIC directorial debut by Neeraj Pandey, and wonderful Cinematography and photography (Fuwad Khan) 10. If we don't send it now for the Oscars - the world won't know that we are "Not resilient by choice, we are resilient by force" Let the world know what the Stupid Common Man of India experiences, and what it needs, what it wants, and what it WILL do if the cockroaches don't stop.
posted 13 September 2008, 01:24 PM UAE time.
Most Read Today
2 Bollywood's take on Mumbai terror attacks
Stars are shocked and shaken
3 Rugby 7s Day 1
First day of Dubai's Rugby 7s ... and the action got into full swing...
4 I am not the only one praising Abhishek
Ash gushes about husband's performance in 'Dostana' and tells why she herself opted out of the movie
5 Dhoni meets Aish
Indian cricket captain spotted on the set of music video













Post your Comment