Features...
Friday, 12 March, 2010
Reviews Print this | Email this |

Now dubbed in Hindi, Kamal Haasan's self-indulgent film is insufferable

by Subhash K. Jha
Kamal Haasan with his family at the premiere of the Hindi version of 'Dashavatar'
picture: Viral Bhayani
Kamal Haasan with his family at the premiere of the Hindi version of 'Dashavatar'

Several hours after I saw the amazing camera chameleon Kamal Haasan transform into 10 utterly different characters, my head was still reeling.

"Is that also him?" my daughter kept asking about every character - man, woman or child - who popped up in this action-reaction drama on the dynamics of destiny, karma, religion, politics and global terrorism.

You have to see "Dashavatar" to know what the astounding Kamal Haasan has attempted and failed to achieve in this woefully ambitious tale of greed and lust for life - and I don't only mean the emotions that motivate the characters.

The actor, who is also the screenwriter of this flamboyant tale of rebellious warriors, international gangs and parochial accents, is also motivated by a lust and ambition for more, more and more of himself on screen. He doesn't just hog footage. He wallows it up without a burp.

On-screen megalomania is not a good thing for the wellbeing of a film. When the actor becomes several sizes larger than the vehicles invented to accommodate his restless talents, its time for the actor to slow down and consider why cinema flourished as an art form in the first place.

Was it so that one day an actor of Kamal Haasan's stature could monopolise screen time to the detriment of all narrative equilibrium?

Indeed, the actor's audacity takes your breath away. Right before our stunned eyes Kamal Haasan transforms into characters ranging from an old cantankerous woman to George Bush.

The funniest of them all is an impersonation of a pompous, parochial Bengali government agent (whose ringtone is R.D. Burman's "Jaane-e-jaan tu kahan main yahan" in Bengali) assigned to bring a global terrorist (played with snarling lipsmacking relish by, who else, Kamal The Chameleon) to book. They chase one another on land and in space. They create mayhem but no pace or space for the narration to breathe in any semblance of grace.

This is an epic that loses control over its resources. A Tamil maestro of the performing arts doing a Bengali accent is as outrageous as Jaya Prada playing the wife of a cancer-stricken Punjabi Bhangra-pop singer.

Oh, didn't I tell you? Kamal Haasan also does a Punjabi. And why not? "Dashavatar" is an ode to Indianess in all its gory glory. It starts several centuries ago and ends in in 2004 with the Tsunami waters creating a havoc and catastrophe (impressively staged) far more containable than what what this film has achieved.

"Dashavatar" is one chaotic, messy and exasperating mass of mammoth ambitions gone awry.

An ongoing theme in all of Kamal Haasan's cinema is the opposition between religion and cynicism. As in real life, in this film the actor (in one of his 10 avatars) is an agnostic who ironically has to run around with a Krishna statue that has a deadly vial secreted in its clay body. Wow, god meets the NASA!

For company, the agnostic has the hysterical Asin screeching and fretting like Kajol on drugs. Then poor Mallika Sherawat appears to perform a snazzy cabaret to an indeterminate Himesh Reshammiya tune and gets impaled to the nearest wall like a comic book Amazon who forgot to let us know she could and would go from oomphy to grisly without bothering about the strange range of moods that this bizarre film covers.

Don't blame her. It's the atmosphere of constant hyper-activity that Kamal Haasan with some help from director Ravi Kumar creates. Some of the aerial action sequences are no doubt breathtaking. And a couple of Kamal Hassan's avatars, especially the Japanese samurai and the wisened senile woman looking for her long-lost son are outright awesome.

By the time the old lady thinks she has found her son, the director has lost the plot. Completely.

This movie is more a triumph of prosthetic excesses than creative passion.

"Dashavatar" is not a bad film. Its worse. Its an insufferable, self-indulgent film.

Cast: Kamal Haasan, Mallika Sherawat, Asin, Jaya Pradha;

Director: K. Ravi Kumar


Kamal Haasan Related Articles & Photos

Breaking News  

Production house slaps lawsuit on Kamal Haasan

He failed to complete their film Read it...

Breaking News  

Kamal Haasan completes 50 years in showbiz

Fans organising big event on Aug 12 Read it...

Breaking News  

Kamal Haasan watches daughter’s debut film

Special prview of ‘Luck’ held in Chennai Read it...

Breaking News  

Rajnikant votes, Kamal Haasan not allowed to

Haasan had cancelled his shooting schedule for polls Read it...

Breaking News  

Shruti busy with dad Kamal Haasan's film

She is composing music for his remake of 'A Wednesday' Read it...

Comments

    comments 1-6 of 6
what a film by mr hassan
by sanjay singhania, delhi, india, USA


i am a regular watcher of HUMAARI HINDI FILMS ONLY ! but on one fine day happened to watch kalhaasans film , and now came to know that people from SOUTH are much greater filmakers than from the north. this we have to agree yaaar ! WHAT a film MINDBLOWING!!!!!!!!!!!!!. i HONESTLY SAY THAT THE SOUTH FILMS ONE DAY WILL DEFINETLY WIN AN OSCAR and there is none better an actor like KAMAL HASSAN TO GET AN OSCAR FOR INDIA. now a days i prefer watching films from south as they are more spaectacular and flamboyant to watch. i thank jha , for without his mindless criticism i would not have watched DASHAVATAAR, WHICH IS A GREAT FILM, WHICH LOOKS LIKE A HOLLYWOOD FILM altogether.
posted 5 May 2009, 07:00 PM UAE time.
Great reveiw by S. K Jha
by hindi bolo


I watched the hindi version of this movie. It is completely disaster. There is no entertainment in this movie. I will say even "Abhay" was better than this. What does Kamal Hassan think of himself? Please stop "emotional atyachaar" . I also don't understand why Nirmal, Kannan are so offended by this review? This movie is going to be Super Flop
posted 26 April 2009, 11:30 AM UAE time.
Kudos mr.jha
by purnima


I couldn't agree less with Mr. Jha. In fact I think he has been very generous with his review. This movie is indeed a self-indulgent project full of crap! I think Kamal Hassan has lost all sense of reality due to his bizarre narcissistic streak. It is sad to see an actor of his stature come up with mindless drivel of this sort. He has tried to hog the limelight in projects earlier too, but managed to get away with most of it. But this is truly insufferable fare, meant only for the mindless viewer. I hope better sense prevails in his forthcoming projects... hope the God he doesn't believe in succeeds in driving some sense into his semi-boiled, half-cooked brains!
posted 26 April 2009, 06:42 AM UAE time.
ONE OF THE WORST REVIEWS EVER
by nirmal, bangalore, india


congrats mr subhash k .jha!!!!! THIS IS THE WORST MOVIEW REVIEW I HAVE EVER SEEN IN MY LIFE. keep up the worst work, as u only can better u'r nonsense reviews!!!!!!!!
posted 22 April 2009, 10:51 PM UAE time.
Dashavatar is a Great Movie
by Anil Gulecha, Pune, India


I have just watched Dashavatar. It is absolutely mind blowing... just watching the pains Kamal Hassan has taken to do 10 different roles. The movie itself is entertaining and technically excellent too... A must watch in a long time.
posted 20 April 2009, 10:13 PM UAE time.
Did u even made any cinema MrSubhash K. Jha
by kannan


who is this Subhash K. Jha ,,,,, what a stupid article he has writen .... dear Masal publishers ,, dont try to be a pakka masala ...please stop this kind of writers ...let me take some lines from Subhash K. Jha ...its for you only ... "When the "writer" becomes several sizes larger than the vehicles invented to accommodate his restless talents, its time for the "writer" to slow down and consider why media flourished as an literature form in the first place.
posted 19 April 2009, 09:34 PM UAE time.

Post your Comment

All posts are sent to the administrator for review and are published only after approval. Ahlan Masala reserves the right to remove any comment at any time for any reason. Please keep your responses appropriate and on topic.
Name *
Remember me on this computer
Email *
(Your email address will not be published)
City
Country
Subject *
Comment *
Notify me of further comments


Please click post only once - your comment will not be published immediately.

Dubai Diaries

Mahiyu Dhanwani's birthday party
Launch of the Zardoze line
City 101.6 Relaunch
Exclusive preview of Iconic
Desibel Night @ Aqua Fuego
Korloff Paris show for DSF Dubai Fashion
Farewell party @ Palm Jumeirah
Burberry show
Special movie screening
 

Most Read Today

Stars at SRK's bash for Akon

Most Read!
Stars at SRK's bash for Akon


A-listers including Priyanka Chopra and Hrithik Roshan partied at SRK’s home

2 The Week's Best Dressed?

Masala! had fun trendspotting at the recently held filmfare awards night

3 ‘Ra.One’ media meet

SRK, Kareena and Akon spoke to the press in Mumbai about the movie

4 Lakme Fashion Week – Celebs on Day 5

Celebs including Freida Pinto and Celina Jetley were at the shows on the last day of LFW

5 ‘Alice in Wonderland’ premiere

Shruti Hassan, her family, and other celebs attended the show in Mumbai